Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 7, 2020

Damore vs. Google: the case for the plaintiff

I relish writing posts like this one because I have absolutely no patience for intellectual dishonesty, and the whole left-ish so-called social justice movement, and so-called diversity and inclusion (D&I), and so-called political correctness (a term that has become one of disapproval, although it didn't have to), as these things have actually been promoted and practiced by left-ish types, have institutionalized intellectual dishonesty to a very considerable extent.  [Follow-up posting on the dishonest dynamic of present-day leftists here.]

One of the basic de facto rules of this bastardized-by-leftish-types form of "social justice" is:

Go out of your way to misrepresent the ideas/arguments of those who challenge the "social justice" orthodoxy.

Another de facto rule:

Make sure, as much as you can get away with, to replace fair argument responsive to what the opponent actually says, with shaming tactics.

Damore says that Google has institutionalized to some extent a culture of shaming and misrepresentation, and based on what evidence I've seen, he's exactly fucking right, and it's the leftish ones who oughtta be ashamed of themselves.

Let's take one example of what the culture at Google instills in its toeing-the-orthodox-line employees:

Former 'Googler' Yonatan Zunger considered it appropriate to chastise Damore thusly:
I’m going to be even blunter than usual here, because I’m not subject to the usual maze of HR laws right now, and so I can say openly what I would normally only be allowed to say in very restricted fora. And this is addressed specifically to the author of this manifesto.
What you just did was incredibly stupid and harmful. You just put out a manifesto inside the company arguing that some large fraction of your colleagues are at root not good enough to do their jobs, and that they’re only being kept in their jobs because of some political ideas. And worse than simply thinking these things or saying them in private, you’ve said them in a way that’s tried to legitimize this kind of thing across the company, causing other people to get up and say “wait, is that right?”
I need to be very clear here: not only was nearly everything you said in that document wrong, the fact that you did that has caused significant harm to people across this company, and to the company’s entire ability to function. And being aware of that kind of consequence is also part of your job, as in fact it would be at pretty much any other job. I am no longer even at the company and I’ve had to spend half of the past day talking to people and cleaning up the mess you’ve made. I can’t even imagine how much time and emotional energy has been sunk into this, not to mention reputational harm more broadly.
And as for its impact on you: Do you understand that at this point, I could not in good conscience assign anyone to work with you? I certainly couldn’t assign any women to deal with this, a good number of the people you might have to work with may simply punch you in the face, and even if there were a group of like-minded individuals I could put you with, nobody would be able to collaborate with them. You have just created a textbook hostile workplace environment.
If you hadn’t written this manifesto, then maybe we’d be having a conversation about the skills you need to learn to not be blocked in your career — which are precisely the ones you described as “female skills.” But we are having a totally different conversation now. It doesn’t matter how good you are at writing code; there are plenty of other people who can do that. The negative impact on your colleagues you have created by your actions outweighs that tremendously.
You talked about a need for discussion about ideas; you need to learn the difference between “I think we should adopt Go as our primary language” and “I think one-third of my colleagues are either biologically unsuited to do their jobs, or if not are exceptions and should be suspected of such until they can prove otherwise to each and every person’s satisfaction.” Not all ideas are the same, and not all conversations about ideas even have basic legitimacy.
If you feel isolated by this, that your views are basically unwelcome in tech and can’t be spoken about… well, that’s a fair point. These views are fundamentally corrosive to any organization they show up in, drive people out, and I can’t think of any organization not specifically dedicated to those views that they would be welcome in. I’m afraid that’s likely to remain a serious problem for you for a long time to come. But our company is committed to maintaining a good environment for all of its people, and if one person is determined to thwart that, the solution is pretty clear.²
I’m writing this here, in this message, because I’m no longer at the company and can say this sort of thing openly. But I want to make it very clear: if you were in my reporting chain, all of part (3) would have been replaced with a short “this is not acceptable” and maybe that last paragraph above. You would have heard part (3) in a much smaller meeting, including you, me, your manager, your HRBP, and someone from legal. And it would have ended with you being escorted from the building by security and told that your personal items will be mailed to you. And the fact that you think this was “all in the name of open discussion,” and don’t realize any of these deeper consequences, makes this worse, not better.


Now, does this sound like a response appropriate to what Damore's manifesto was actually saying, or does it sound more like a lack of willingness to properly engage with Damore's context and replace it instead with strident virtue-signaling?  It sounds a lot more like the latter to me.  What it tells me is that the mentality displayed here is cultivated at Google to such an extent that what really happened is that Google exercised no due diligence/effort to explain to Damore how/where his ideas went wrong, how they present a potential danger of contributing to a hostile work environment, and how he might have the opportunity to correct his errors before it's determined that he and Google aren't a good fit.  (It turns out they aren't a good fit, if the above response to a good-faith presentation of putative science and fact is more or less the "best" that Damore could expect from the company.)

In short: does it sound like this chastisement is written with the aim in mind of anticipating how Damore might respond, or is it basically a one-sided rant?

I recommend reading some of the comments that follow, particularly the quality and tone of those who applaud and pile on.  Do they demonstrate a willingness to actually understand Damore's views, or are they really quick to conclude that he must have been promoting the loathsome ideas they attribute to him?  Keep in mind, as you answer this, the general culture of the American left today when it comes to characterizing opposing views they don't like: are they more likely than not to misrepresent - sometimes blatantly and obviously - their opponents' positions?  Are they more likely than not to jump to the conclusion that a debatable point is instead racist, sexist, etc. and therefore beyond the pale of rational argument?

Because that's the pattern I've been observing on the left these past few years now, and it's fucking disgusting.

Now, contrast the righteous rant from Mr. Zunger above with this comment (by James Gillmore), and see whether you think one is making more of an effort at dialogue, understanding and actual empathy than the other:




After having of course read the manifesto and responded to various comments, here’s my response to one of the comments:
“And the answer to the million dollar question is this [i.e. what the young man should have been told, i.e. what would have been far more helpful]:
“Historically [and currently basically everywhere that doesn’t have these policies], it’s been the other way around, where male-dominated work culture has led to a lot of unfair circumstances for female employees. We’re slowly improving, but we aren’t there yet. In an ideal world, such policies wouldn’t need to exist. For now, we’ve deemed the best thing we can do is offset the imbalance of power as best we can and create a welcoming environment as equally as possible for all. Yes, the policies are an unnatural construct for a larger even more unnatural construct: mega corporations, which can no longer be truly accountable for the people they bring on board. The best answer is JUST TO BE NON-DISCRIMINATORY, but since we are so focused on the greed of our ambitions of growth, becoming small and guaranteeing that is not something we care about. The cost is it leaves males wondering if they are now the ones at a disadvantage, and females doubting whether they earned their position. It’s an imperfect system in an imperfect world, but regardless you are here, and you competed against hundreds of thousands of others, so rest assured you’re more than worthy of your position; and if you’re a male, you’re male after all, toughen up, be a gentlemen and look out for the women in your group! You’re a technologist after all, it’s easier than ever to carve up your own path; if you don’t like it you’re free to go.
*the second to last sentence is an imperfect addendum in an imperfect world that will always be loose around the edges; I don’t think it creates any value to pretend it’s something it’s not.”
And a related response to another thoughtful commenter is this:
“My overall response to what you’re saying — and it’s not something I disagree with — is that the degree of response to this young man also must be just. It’s not just “about degree” — DEGREE IS EVERYTHING. What he’s been grappling with isn’t abnormal — and if the only response is over-reactions like what he received from the now-ex-googler who felt it was his job to bring down the hammer, I don’t think we’re gonna make any progress evolving humanity.
“Here’s the thing: when wrongs or violence (real or imagined or virtual) are acted upon someone, you are more inclined to feel for a victim who is a friend. That’s how empathy is developed. But if everyone is enemies (like Zunger just declared), both sides won’t see each other as friends and will have no motivation to understand each other. That’s why this young man doesn’t understand the pain women have gone through in the workplace, and it’s why women and men like Zunger don’t understand his. Not the pain he’s been through likely as a social outcast, and not the obvious pain of being virtually executed as he has been today. It’s shocking that people can’t put themselves in the shoes of said young men, and instead rejoice in his summary execution — especially when that’s exactly what they are asking of said young man. 2 wrongs don’t make a right. In fact, if this was a relationship and real life (not just a blog article Zunger can distance himself from), it’s usually the person who overreacts that ends up being far more in the wrong and having to clean up the mess (if she/he is a brave well-intentioned individual). If you’ve been in any sort of fight with your significant other and overreacted, you know exactly what I’m talking about.
“With no room for dialog, there is no understanding, and no evolution of viewpoints. Things absolutely can’t be black and white. Similar to good music and art being all about nuance to create a mood, to have any sort of effect, nuance and degree are paramount.
“Some people say “well, the line has to be drawn somewhere.” Definitely, there are cases where fighting back to avoid extinction is the only option. This isn’t one of them. Not the way Zunger handled it. And such circumstances are truly rare at the end of the day.
“The young man wrote a manifesto after all — that means he was open to dialog. In the above link I propose what he should have been told. Catch-22 or not [i.e. the commenter I was responding to pointed out that the manifesto writer put Google in a position of a catch-22, for if they now fired him, that only proves his point that Google isn’t truly inclusive], he can be assertively told why things are the way they are — and actually, there is no catch-22. There’s a reason these policies exist. I agree that a giant cancerous mega corp needs them. So they should simply be able to explain it to said young man. If they can’t, or their unofficial representatives can’t, without overreacting, that’s a problem. If they don’t understand how young males may struggle getting it, that’s really on them and a problem that may in fact be bigger at this point in time.
“Overall I didn’t find Zunger’s response very well thought out, but just a way to jump in a pool of automatic validation and be the hero where one wasn’t really needed — since after all Google does have these policies in place and is willing to act on them; I’m sure said young man will be fired. And no, I don’t think that the young kid or man deserves this sorta smackdown. It’s not right. I’m sorry, it’s just not. No matter, if it’s some manipulative catch-22 ploy by said young man [because said young man is struggling in the workplace because of his actions toward the opposite sex and the negative response from his superiors, and was manipulating to flip the script in his favor, as the commenter I responded to was guessing].
“If Google can’t come up with something to do with him, they’re lacking in imagination and just proves my point that giant centralized corps are on the outs. The young man isn’t Geoffrey Dommer and instead requires guidance. That level of engagement unfortunately is something you rarely find in society. What you get primarily is asshole patriarchal figures like Zunger Games. Keep that in mind when you think of young men — it’s not like the world is brimming with guidance for how to be a “modern man,” while the world is still figuring it out. [in essence, empathy is required at all levels to live up to the pursuit of inclusivity]
“Just take a moment and imagine this was your son. All of 23 years old and possibly social awkward. Imagine him younger, say 10 — where do you draw the line? Now, imagine he’s on the spectrum — after all, we are all on some sort of spectrum as nobody is a master of every circumstance. Would a profile picture that shows he clearly is autistic or has aspergers change things?
“What would you allow to be said to your son in this situation? Imagine your son is 10 and comes to you and says: ‘Mommy/Daddy, why do the girls get to go to the free after school tutoring program, but I don’t and I’m the one who’s failing?” What would you tell him. And at what age does it become unacceptable for him to even ask? Too much power has been given to said young man. He’s likely an insecure young man who just arrived in a workplace with these policies (even if that was 5 years ago), and has known no other. To cast him out as a social reject is bad policy. He will act out like a child you don’t truly engage.
“He’s not alone in the question he had — even for man in their 20s or 30s. Lots of men are wondering this same thing, especially as the world does evolve to incorporate these policies. We aren’t talking Don Drapers coming from a place of status like Zunger. We aren’t talking the scary men in positions of power that women feel psychological acts of violence from. All of this must be considered to have the most effective biggest picture thinking, and grow young men of the future who truly and innately get it. Who don’t feel an entitlement to the workplace over women. Who view women as equals.
“We’re creating the world as we speak, and there are no hard and fast rules (at least not on a public stage). So it’s detrimental that we’re as inclusive and cooperative as possible in ALL circumstances, rather than assume our point of view is so right that it justifies enacting virtual/psychological acts of violence towards another. That’s precisely the pain women feel based on previous work conditions (and current). If nothing else, Zunger made it ok to treat people like that when you feel justified.
“People every day feel justified in actions, only to either realize they’re wrong, or for everyone else to realize it. That’s the “catch-22” of allowing for such harsh over-reactions — you’re not always going to be “right.” If there is a “rule,” it should be that you should always leave room for error and to be wrong. Degree is important, process (how you go about things) is important. I’m sorry, this isn’t the process. It’s just not.
“Let me know your thoughts on what I proposed the response should be. Perhaps we can craft that together.”






So that’s the latest. I urge everyone to think with as big of a picture as possible when discussing this. This isn’t somehow some easy obvious topic, like Zunger indicated, conveniently allowing him to skip over it. If it was, this wouldn’t be happening. Manifestos wouldn’t be going out, you wouldn’t be hearing about it all year in the tech press. The policies wouldn’t exist in the first place. This is an opportunity for the tech world to really champion some challenging issues while showing the world both sides can come to a collective solution.
Lambasting either side isn’t the way. It makes zero sense for said young man to write the most thoughtful assessment he could come up with, and to be shutdown so harshly with zero explanation, given what I’ve pinpointed out about growing understanding men of the future. He truly doesn’t get it. And the other side truly doesn’t get that he doesn’t get it. Nobody gets anything because there is no communication. Everybody is enemies. Nobody is friends. Nobody has any natural motivation to empathize with the other side and understand their pain.
That’s all it would take for said young man to get why the policies are in place, and not end up writing a manifesto that frames women as less fit than men in the workplace. And if not him, at least the next young man.
Doing what Zunger did, as heroic as it might seem, just perpetuates a world where nobody is motivated to understand each other. What he has done creates enemies. And yes, there’s a place to draw the line, but degree is absolutely everything. I suggest to people who side with the young manifesto writer to seek to understand the psychological violence women feel is and has been enacted upon them throughout history by men assuming they are unfit, and I suggest to the women and men who don’t seem to understand this young man to recognize he’s not coming from a place of power like a CEO, he’s likely insecure, young, introverted and the only work world he has ever known is where there are policies which seem to put him at a disadvantage. (And also think of him as if he was your struggling child and Zunger just did this to him). In other words, he doesn’t recognize his own power/value. Neither side does.
Just maybe this young man could be a convert if he was talked to another way.
Lastly, the problem of the people of planet earth is simply that they retaliate too easily. If we don’t evolve past that, we’ll destroy the planet. Especially given how fast technology has evolved in the recent stint of peace that we take for granted.


Now, this comment sounds like basic common sense, i.e.: what about Damore's context?  Should that be taken into account a lot more before firing him?  And is it Google & Zunger's assumption that Damore is not amenable to correction where that may be warranted?  And is such an assumption an honest one?

I think the linked medium thread captures in a nutshell, at the level of metadata as it were, the way the left-ish quasi-egalitarian SJ/PC/D&I [sic] crowd tends to conduct itself in (sorry excuses for) debates.  The pattern repeats itself all over the place in the news.  They smeared Prof. Wax as a racist for her "bourgeois values" argument.  They smear Trump and his supporters all the time as racists, sexist, etc., and most often where they have no clear warrant in doing so.  I think it's all quite fucking shameful and anti-philosophical.  Now, are they open to correction wherever that is much warranted?  Well, there's the free-will answer - they ultimately have it within them to stop being such epistemically-unjust pieces of shit - and then there's the "what is the prevailing culture of leftish doctrine and practice nowadays" answer - i.e., they seem pretty steadfastly committed to remaining epistemically unjust pieces of shit for the foreseeable future, alarm bells ringing and all.

I think that if indeed it's Mr. Zunger's post more than Mr. Gillmore's (the latter's) that represents the mentality in Google's HR, then Google deserves every PR hit from this that it gets.  Zunger's rant may have the surface appearance (to the less discerning) of being solution-oriented, but it's not.  Whatever benefit Damore might have gotten from it is drowned out by the negativity of it and the jumping to various conclusions about him that have the actual function of being mean-spirited and destructive rather than constructive.  Gillmore's post is quite clearly more solution-oriented.

So basically the gist of today's leftish so-called 'diversity and inclusion' movement amounts to this: if you don't toe the line and accept the orthodox assumptions, if you challenge those assumptions (pointedly or otherwise), if you speak your mind as classic rules of free and open dialogue would encourage while presenting what is not obviously bad evidence that runs counter to the orthodox narrative, if you are basically intellectually honest in the process . . . that's not going to help you.  You are likely to be misrepresented, shamed, canceled, unplatformed, smeared, piled on, and generally treated with epistemically-unjust disrespect.  If you're a white male, you're likely to be told that you're coming from a standpoint of privilege and that you fail to empathize with those less privileged, and those telling you that will see no irony in any of this.

One of the virtues that many people see in Trump is his willingness to treat this horseshit for what it is: to call out those who engage in it as the ones who should be shamed for their dishonesty.  When Trump says he has no time for political correctness (sic), what he's actually saying is that he has no time for a culture of systemic dishonesty masquerading as being politically correct.  Damore wasn't being dishonest or disrespectful.  I can't say the same for Google or Zunger.

And that's really what all this comes down to.  Is the predominant intellectual culture of today's left (especially the further left you go) honest and respectful?  No, it is not.  It encourages scumminess toward those who don't toe the line, whatever their reasons for not assenting.  The pattern repeats itself so much and so often as to be unmistakable.  To bring up yet another example on top of the gobs of them already linked in this blog's postings: David Horowitz, ex-New Leftist.  Did his leftist former friends and colleagues treat his 'apostasy' with honesty and respect, or with malice and logically-slipshod/lazy or outright groundless shaming?  The latter(, of course).

But let's not forget about the source of what Google HR, the Demo-rats, the mural-erasing San Francisco school board, the Rand-bashers, the Sowell-ignorers, the Title IX kangaroo court managers, the 'diversity and inclusion' hypocrites, the rent-controllers, the race-hustlers, the #MeToo abusers/Swetnick-believers, the biological-males-in-women's-sports activists, CNN/MSDNC/NYT, the illegal immigration incentivizers, the suspiciously eager gun-grabbers, and the rest of the sorry bunch & enablers have been up to: All of this is egged on and made possible by the fundamentally, systemically dishonest Academic Left who've squandered every benefit of the doubt by this point.  (Let's not forget the hubris that leads them to the notion that those who disagree with them are invariably intellectually and morally inferior - and to their tailoring their response to uncomfortable triggering arguments/ideas accordingly, typically by characterizing them as worse than they are or were ever intended to be.)  If you suspect that someone like Damore is much more a victim than an offender in this affair, you would possess way more common sense and decency than this bunch of loathsome losers.

[Addendum: Is there a case in all fairness to be made for the defendant?  Well, how about this for fairness: Google gets just as much of a fair hearing as they gave Damore - which is to say, jack shit.  Got a problem with that?  How about this to boot: its CEO is a doubletalking, chickenshit appeaser who damn well oughtta know better what is required of treating people with basic decency and respect, as opposed to giving into blatantly obvious illogic and smears.  Treating Zunger and Gillmore even so much as on par with one another = Asshole.  [Alternatively: the cases for the defendant and plaintiff were already pretty much made by Zunger and Gillmore, respectively.  In the linked thread Zunger was cheered on by lesser, sloppy minds even though it's clear to any careful and honest observer which of the two had the upper hand in justice.  Zunger's case is roughly about as "good" as we can expect from the Google side (and note how one-sided it is while purporting to be fair-minded), and under Gillmore-like scrutiny the Google/Zunger case is despicable - and deep down every person of justice knows it, which is why so many are alarmed and pissed about this.  The NLRB having made an Orwellian-style determination in Google's favor changes none of this; it is out of its depth on the fundamental matter of justice/fairness here and it's sad to see "social justice" illogic spread into taxpayer-supported agencies.]]

[Addendum #2: Heterodox Academy carries out an analysis of the data/studies about the Greater Male Variability Hypothesis that the powers that be at Google were too cowardly, dishonest, and PC-whipped to conduct.  And to further contextualize, this critique of Damore's argument tries to be fair/charitable, and for the most part it is, but I don't think entirely.  (It's definitely better than Zunger's anti-charity bullshit.)  But whether it's entirely fair is pretty much neither here nor there in this context.  What this critique represents is something that Google didn't seem to even attempt before firing Damore without further inquiry, i.e., actually present a substantive critique.  And while this critique isn't presented in a format that gives the critique-ee (Damore) a chance to respond, revise, reconsider, relent, etc., Google certainly had a moral obligation to give him that chance, in the spirit of fair and honest dialectic or exchange of ideas in the common pursuit of truth, but can one reasonably conclude that Google did so?  Or is the reasonable conclusion that it was being chickenshit, dishonest, etc.?  You have my verdict on that.]

Sunday, September 29, 2019

Demo rats and impeachment: much worse than partisan hypocrisy

I wrote a post on the general topic of Demo rats and impeachment just yesterday, but I want to focus in on one essential point I raised there to highlight how monstrous these creatures have become these days:
This is the group of creatures, remember, whose standards for impeachment (of their political opponents, that is) is such that they were rushing to call for impeachment of Kavanaugh on no good evidence whatsoever (all the while letting a Demo rat president get away with obvious perjury - how intellectually and morally perverted is that?).  They can't be trusted.
The Demo rats' treatment of Kavanaugh was beyond the pale, clearly so, enough to disgust even some Dems who apparently didn't speak out loud enough against the obvious perversity.  If ever the 'rats destroyed their intellectual and moral credibility, it is because of their reckless attempt to destroy Kavanaugh.

What the current crop of filthy, disgusting, toxic slime known as the Democratic leadership in Congress and their enablers in the media and elsewhere consider to be justified, is the following:

Impeach and/or destroy someone without any credible evidence
and
Let someone else get away with obvious perjury

In other words, knowingly and deliberately punish the (presumed) innocent and let the (clearly) guilty go unpunished.

This isn't comparing like with like and then pointing to a partisan double standard.  This is more sick and twisted than that.  It's one thing to be a partisan hypocrite; it's another to uphold utterly opposed standards of evidence and punishment on purely partisan grounds.  That makes the destroy-Kavanaugh crowd unqualified evil-doers, people who have no business having power in a sane and civil polity.  Morally speaking they are criminals operating under the pretense of doing hardball politics.  They are beyond the pale.  They are sick and twisted fucks.  They are not owed respect, deference, the presumption of good faith, the presumption that they are decent human beings.  The proper attitude to take to the sort of people who adhere to the even-worse-than-double-standard above is one of distrust and enmity.  They are enemies of the good and decency.  They contravene the spirit if not letter of the Constitution they swore to uphold, when they so extremely pervert law and justice (whether for partisan ends or anything else).  They are thugs and should be regarded as such.

Sen. Graham put it in less harsh tones:


If this is the sort of outright perversity that is being normalized, enabled, abetted, excused, not spoken out against, etc., on today's American left, then that speaks even worse about them than everything else I've been criticizing them for up to now.  This puts them into a different category of evil.  There is no good reason whatsoever to concede intellectual and moral credibility to any of the left/Dems/"progressives" who failed to do the right thing during or after the Kavanaugh episode.

If anything, it is the likes of Scumbag Kamala Harris who should be impeached, formally censured, or otherwise punished for fraudulently using the judicial process as a weapon of personal and political destruction.  In no uncertain terms is she and her behavior fraudulent: this career prosecutor declared that she believed Kavanaugh's accuser before hearing the defense's side.  Other leading Demo rat politicians (including Warren, Biden and Sanders) are on the record affirming that Kavanaugh's accuser was credible (and Kavanaugh not credible) enough that Kavanaugh's career should be ended.  (Of course, they accuse Kavanaugh of lying under oath to the Judiciary Committee, in which case the mere usual ol' double standard is at play: they let Clinton get away with perjury but found Kavanaugh's "unacceptable."  Actually, it's obvious Clinton lied; is it obvious in any way that Kavanaugh did?  So even there it's not comparing like with like.)  They fed and enabled media and grass roots hysteria about Kavanaugh's "credible accusers."  And they repeated the same vile act, recklessly rushing to raise or renew calls for impeachment within minutes of "new" allegations coming to light just in the past month that turned out to be a dud along with the others.

This is dead-to-rights stuff if ever there was any.  These creatures don't even meet minimal standards of basic decency.  They can't be treated as co-equals in a search for truth because they sabotage the very underpinnings of that.  It is intellectual and moral bankruptcy, if not outright malicious evil, not to recognize and repudiate this sub-decent, beyond-the-pale-even-for-politics perversity for what it is.  And that appears to be the intellectual and moral state of the American left today.  On the merits their intellectual and moral credibility are utterly destroyed.  It doesn't please me to say such things, but it's where the totality of the evidence inexorably leads.

Sunday, September 15, 2019

Demo rats vs. Kavanaugh, again

The rat-like elected creatures of one of the two major political parties seem to operate on the assumption that the rest of us think and moralize as sloppily and dishonestly as they do.  The latest accusations against now-Justice Kavanaugh does not (and cannot) vindicate these creatures and what they were up to the last time around.

They blew their credibility when they deemed credible the evidence-lacking accusations made against him in 2018 (including, as in the case of Sen. Warren, the ridiculous repeat-drugged-gang-rapes allegation from Swetnick).

They looked the other way when a Demo rat president was accused of rape.

They refused to impeach a Demo rat president even though he lied under oath, even as they now call for the impeachment of Trump and Kavanaugh.

They looked the other way when Demo rats in the highest offices in the state of Virginia faced scandals and Republicans would be their replacements.  (When it comes to comparable claims made against Republicans, they routinely immediately assume the worst.)  As one article put it, Demo rats were rendered speechless as scandal engulfed Virginia's Demo rat leadership.  Isn't being caught dead to rights something that naturally causes speechlessness?  (Rand-bashers also get speechless - and also not contrite - when their reckless misrepresentations and smears are refuted.)  They have no defense for their blatant double standards, after all, and no one will believe their bullshit anyway.

This isn't to comment on the credibility of the latest accusation or new shit brought to light by the latest NYT piece.  It is, however, to say that Demo rat politicians (along with various others in the media) should be left out of any discussion of these things, as they only bring toxicity and deliberate partisan water-muddying.

I mean, think about it from the perspective of anyone who wants to build a credible case against Kavanaugh: how on earth would such a person make any use of anything that the elected rats have had to say on the matter?  Bringing in what they say could only damage one's credibility.

It's epistemic chickens coming home to roost, is all.  The bums lost.  If getting Kavanaugh ousted is what justice requires, then let's find some credible spokespeople for the cause, which means encouraging the elected rats to STFU so they don't manage to build sympathy for their target.

Addendum: Any responsible inquiry into this sort of thing will involve looking at the pushback from the other side, which Demo rats clearly refuse to do.  One example: "What Pogrebin and Kelly left out of their story, yet reported in their book, is that the alleged victim doesn’t remember the incident and refuses to talk about it. That’s journalistic malpractice."  Is it really too much to ask for "reporters" at "the paper of record" to, well, report such things in their article?  (Using the Witch Hunt Epistemology of the Demo rats, the alleged victim's lack of memory should probably be attributed to drunkenness on her part.)  (The linked NY Post piece also discusses - although this isn't new - the glaring holes in the Ramirez story about drunken junk-exposing at Yale.)  Or: how is it that the author of the National Review piece could come up with ample grounds for skepticism, right on the spot (namely: how does the logistics of a classmate directing someone else's junk work?  Witch Hunt answer: Kavanaugh must have been so blacked-out drunk that he didn't mind someone else pushing his junk in this or that direction), whereas elected rats treat the allegations as a basis for impeachment?  (The phrase "journalistic malpractice" also comes up in that piece, for the same reason.  So either some coordination of talking points is going on, or the authors are simply speaking common sense, independently.  And it is common sense.  The "paper of record" apparently lacks it.)  One of the rats, Scumbag Kamala Harris - again, a career prosecutor who cannot fail to know about the obligation to hear both sides before rendering a verdict - appears to believe (both in 2018 and this time around) allegations after having heard only the allegation-side.  Other things being equal, it is better for such a rat to remain a Senator where the alternative is being elevated to President.  [Edit 9/16: Six '20 Demo rats on twitter immediately called for impeachment after the latest "news": Scumbag Harris, the two outright fools O'Rourke and Castro, Warren, Sanders and Booker [edit: Mayor Pete].  Scumbag Harris in particular claims that Kavanaugh lied to the Senate in his confirmation hearings.  This is one example of how destructive a format twitter is.  A "longer" format would virtually call forth evidence for such a serious charge, some weblink or explanation or other, because unlike Scumbag Harris many Americans don't find it remotely obvious that he lied to the Senate.  But this serially dishonest and unaccountable, and ultimate unimpressive creature abuses the twitter format to make unfounded charges.  How is she supposed to be better or more impressive than the Orange Man?]

Addendum #2: Even if Kavanaugh lied to Congress, that doesn't in any way vindicate or excuse the rats' epistemic criminality.  (Heck, even if the accusations against him are true, the Dems did a terrible job of justifying their position that the accusations were credible, just as they routinely do a terrible job justifying their positions generally nowadays.  Heck, even if Republicans are scumbags, that still doesn't vindicate Demo rats.  The best they could hope to show in that case is that they're less scummy than Republicans, but I very much doubt that they could show that, either.  Today's Demo rat party is too much of a sick puppy and, given the nature of epistemic justification, if they happen to be right about something [e.g. climate change] it is an accident.  Since when do Demo rats listen to experts on subjects where the expertise would not vindicate the Dem viewpoint?  They routinely ignore the majority of economists when it comes to the minimum wage, for example.  And anyway, neither Dems nor Reps have particularly good arguments for rejecting libertarianism, and neither party is remotely progressive when it comes to philosophical education of the citizenry which is far and away the biggest no-brainer of all time.)

Addendum #3: Some more pro-Kavanaugh commentary that the epistemically reckless Demo rats ("epistemically reckless" is the minimum charge I would level at these willfully scummy creatures) can be relied upon to deliberately/culpably ignore: Dreher and Kimball.  And it's not like it pleases me to say that the only thing Demo rats are reliable about these days is being intellectually reckless, lazy, etc.  I would rather that they behave like decent human beings.

Wednesday, July 17, 2019

Civic ignorance & jury nullification

"A man I found guilty of dealing drugs died in prison. I wish I could take that verdict back."


If you poll Americans on whether they know about jury nullification, the numbers would be appallingly, deplorably low.

Obvious question: why the appalling, deplorable ignorance?  Levels of knowledge or ignorance of jury nullification should be a knock-down, no-brainer litmus test of the quality of civic education in this country.  Someone has really fucked up there, and that someone is probably shifting blame for the problems in this country.

For fuck's sake, already.

Tuesday, July 2, 2019

Reminder: Leading '20 Dems smeared Kavanaugh

In the polling (not as much the betting markets) the leading 2020 Democratic candidates are: Biden, Harris, Warren and Sanders.

All four of them got in on the act of recklessly smearing Brett Kavanaugh, when the chips were down, when a man's career and reputation were on the line.  It reveals not just an intellectual bankruptcy in the Democrat Party, but also a moral bankruptcy.

I've commented in detail on this before. (the context)  A brief recap:

(1) Biden is quoted by AP (9/28/18) as saying that Dr. Ford, Kavanaugh's accuser, gave credible testimony (9/27/18) and that both he and the country believed her.

(2) Harris appeared on CNN on 9/18/18, two days after Ford's accusation became public, to say she believed Dr. Ford.  This career prosecutor said this before hearing from both sides.  This is in addition to her almost surreal interrogation of Kavanaugh in the main portion of the confirmation hearings (where it turns out Harris wasn't holding any cards).

(3) Warren on her facebook page (9/28/18) referred to "multiple, credible accusations" against Kavanaugh, including the ridiculous Swetnick allegation of serial drugged gang rapes (which not only falls apart on its merits but about which Swetnick herself fell apart under scrutiny).

(It should be noted that all three of the above are career attorneys, charged with the professional duty to assess the credibility of putative evidence with care.)

(4) Sanders, in a 9/27/18 press release on his own Senate website, said he believes Dr. Ford.

Ford couldn't remember details about time or place of the alleged incident.  Not only that, no one else came forward to say where and when this event might have taken place.  Not only that, all of the supposed witnesses to the alleged event, including her friend Leland Keyser, provided sworn statements - statements Biden and Warren, at least, chose unaccountably to disregard - that they have no memory of the alleged event.  Not only that, Kavanaugh supplied what would be exculpatory evidence in the calendar he kept.

All this, while fellow Democrats and their enablers in the media either fed the anti-Kavanaugh hysteria (which exploited and weaponized the otherwise honorable and valuable #MeToo movement) or failed to speak up about the injustice of the smear campaign.  This goes, as far as I can tell, for all the other '20 Democrat candidates.  This goes for the Democrats on the Judiciary Committee who withheld Ford's accusation for weeks until leaking them to the press at the last minute.  My sentiments are with Sen. Graham.

Well-placed outrage













Donald Trump hasn't forgotten about any of this, and will do whatever he can in the general election to eat them alive because of it.  As far as I'm concerned, these four leading candidates are caught dead to rights in their epistemic criminality, which they conducted for the sake of power and partisanship.  I have some choice expletives for these creatures which I'll refrain from stating here.

What these Demon Rats would have you believe is that their media-frenzy-fed-and-feeding smear campaign is normal and acceptable.  They might have you believe that this smear campaign was necessary because the man accused wasn't just anybody, but someone who would assume a position of great power and therefore needs extra "scrutiny."  And they would gaslight the rest of us when it comes to standards of evidence and credibility.  They then turn around and give fellow Demon Rats a pass under similar circumstances.  And if they're this bad when it comes to this no-brainer, how bad must they be on matters of ideology and policy, pray tell?  This is the best crop of leading candidates this party can come up with?

The only '20 Dem candidate with much of any prominence in the polling or betting markets, who hasn't morally and intellectually stained himself with this ugliness (except perhaps with his silence about this intended injustice), is Mayor Pete.

"But Trump" or "but Kavanaugh's high school yearbook" (whatever that shows) won't save them from the truth of their own sliminess.

What makes them think they can get away with what they did?

Sunday, June 23, 2019

Will slavery-reparations debates be intellectually bankrupt?

Or will the debates be informed by articles like this one, from a professor at a highly-ranked philosophy program?

Which only invites the question: on what other subjects could the national debate be improved by input from philosophers?

Is Ta-Nehisi Coates the strongest representative for the pro-reparations argument (for either citing or attacking)?  Wouldn't black people benefit tremendously from their case being put forward most prominently/visibly by a philosopher?  Etc. etc. etc.

Shouldn't black kids be put on a vigorous philosophy for children regimen (along with all the other children of course) so that, when older and in concert, they could make their case most strongly (and know the other side's case just as well, etc.)?

Sunday, January 27, 2019

Applied philosophy for children: An NFL do-over? (you know, for the kids)

This is part of a new series of blog posts on philosophy for children - far and away the biggest no-brainer in history - and I can't think of a better time for kid-accessible applied philosophy at the present time than the case of the worst no-call of all-time.  It has raised important ethical questions as to whether the Super Bowl is tainted.

In my earlier post I gave my reasons for regarding a Rams-[AFC Team] Super Bowl tainted due to the horrible officiating, and that the Rams in the name of honor and fair play should agree to a quick and easy do-over like the kids could figure out so easily in their street games.  They even admitted to cheating, so why not own up to that in action?  (Just resume it from where the game was assuming the play was called correctly, if the Saints score a touchdown they go the Super Bowl and if the Rams stop them they go.  The poor referee [I know, I've been there, but come on, man, ffs] even gets to save face.)

I mean, let's say the NFL asked the kids - their most important fan base, currently and long term (this sport is like pro wrestling but not all scripted; I liked both as a kid but outgrew only one of the two...), what they think the fair thing would be to do.  A do-over, right?

Should honor require the Rams to admit what getting away with a really significant cheat entails ethically, and to accept a do-over?  What do principles of justice and virtue (honor being among them) require here?  That would be a great exercise in getting the ball rolling in getting the kids to think philosophically.  Yes? :)

Oh, and wouldn't that be a lot better for the ratings (you know, for the adults)?  Not just the do-over, but the Super Bowl itself, which I and many others are planning as of now to avoid....

[In the posting queue: 'Ultimate Blogging tips: for Philosophers' ^_^ ]

Saturday, January 26, 2019

Is the upcoming Super Bowl tainted?




It sure is, in my opinion.

The Rams were almost certainly put into the Super Bowl by shitty officiating.  Now here comes the moral question: if the Rams are honorable, shouldn't they concede the NFC slot in the Super Bowl to the Saints?  Just because the referee fucks up, making the most obviously shitty no-call of all time, that doesn't mean that the Rams just have to accept the non-decision, right?  They know they committed pass interference, so why do they think it's okay to get away with blatant cheating?  Can't exceptions to rigid rule-keeping be made when the injustice of their observance is so obvious in some cases?  Especially when the rules were so obviously contravened in this case?

What lesson is this supposed to say to the nation's youth?  Their soccer team gets screwed by a referee's call but then again remember how arguably the best team in football in 2019 was screwed by the refs, so suck it up, kids.  Something like that?  You want to breed cynicism into them?  Actually, don't the kids have a way of resolving such injustices -- a do-over?  They're setting a better example than the adults are, ffs.

So I guess there is by default a team to root for in the Super Bowl as is this year, the ones who aren't dishonorable cheaters, and that would be the AFC team.  Right?  Put the Saints in the Super Bowl as they deserve, and we've got a non-Patriots team to root for once again.  Drew Brees deserves the chance, and he had one of his fine on-target passes broken up by a cheating player who openly admits he should have been penalized.

C'mon, Rams and/or NFL, do the right thing.

ADDENDUM: Here's the fairest idea I can think of.  Give the Saints-Rams a do-over from the time and spot of the un-called foul.  Like just televised from a practice field or whatever, relatively quick and easy.  Then everyone's consciences can be clean.  Yes? :)

[Addendum #2 1/27/19: An updated version of the do-over idea is available here and integrated to the most overwhelmingly important topic at present, philosophy for kids.]

Friday, January 25, 2019

Should social media influence be redistributed?

According to the moral code advanced by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and other redistributionists of the left, is it morally acceptable for some people to have way more social influence and fame than others?

Take Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, for example. She possesses a level of charisma and social-media savvy that a lot of other people don't, and she exploits these talents to maximum advantage while others of greater merit remain relatively obscure.  She has shot to social-stardom levels in a short period of time even though the public could barely name even the most prominent philosophers alive who've put in years of hard intellectual work.  How many of AOC's zillions of twitter followers have even heard of Kripke, Chalmers, Williamson, et al, much less the philosophers who do partake in social media (namely in longer-form, more thought-intensive blogging)?  Philosophers are way more thoughtful and learned than AOC (and their blogs way less toxic than her twitter feed), so why don't they get the attention she does?

Social influence is a highly valued and sought after thing, much like money/wealth. Shouldn't AOC feel guilty and be willing to have her social influence redistributed to the less fortunate?

Tuesday, January 22, 2019

Even Rawls allows for billionaires



[See also: the deadly vice of envy]

One of these two has put a lot of time and thought into moral questions and is taken seriously by philosophers; the other is a philosophically illiterate know-nothing who pretends otherwise and basically operates on emotion.

For context: Among academic philosophers, John Rawls (A Theory of Justice, 1971) is the most influential political philosopher of the last half century, with fellow Harvard colleague Robert Nozick (Anarchy, State, and Utopia, 1974), in 2nd place.  (The most influential political philosopher in that period of time, inside or outside the academy, and in terms of impact on the whole community of American thinkers and not just academics, is probably Ayn Rand (Atlas Shrugged, 1957), self-described "radical for capitalism" but in essential alignment with Nozick's libertarianism on this stuff (individuals' lives are their own and not others' to dispose of, basically).)

In Rawlsian justice, the Difference Principle holds that social and economic inequalities are acceptable if they are of greatest benefit to the least advantaged, among all realistically feasible outcomes.  The Difference Principle would be consistent with the most well-off person holding over a billion dollars in wealth as long as the (or a representative) least well-off person or group is better off than they would be under any feasible alternative scenario.  Even economic rightists who otherwise tend to reject Rawlsian justice on grounds that it is too egalitarian and/or redistributivist could readily concede that the Difference Principle still allows for this.

Take a society without billionaires -- all societies of centuries ago or numerous countries in sub-Saharan Africa today.  Nearly everyone in the society is poor, some extremely poor.

Then take a society that has billionaires -- such as a G7 nation today.  Living standards, using all sorts of quality of life measures, are higher pretty much all across the board in comparison/contrast to societies without billionaries; indeed, the relatively least-well-off in a G7 nation may be very much more well-off than a person at (say) the median in the society without billionaires.

By Rawlsian standards, the G7 nation would appear to do a markedly better job than the nations without billionaires of approaching the requirements of the Difference Principle.  There's nothing about the inequality in the G7 nation that morally rules out the existence of billionaires as such.  This doesn't mean that some G7 citizens still won't have a hard time making ends meet by contrast with the G7 nation's rich; it's just that under the usual economic constraints faced by people, we are dealing with what is feasible: in order to have a society with the living standards seen in G7 countries, there will most likely have to be billionaires.  It is hard to believe that any serious student of economics isn't aware of this reality.

So when some know-nothing member of Congress comes along and says that a society that allows for billionaires is morally objectionable, even when the representative least-well-off person in that society is markedly better-off than those of the non-billionaire-having society, and this know-nothing sports an economics degree no less, we might safely conclude that such a person is a moral idiot (and/or that an economics degree means all that much less than it should).

It's like such know-nothings take pride in being ignorant.

(This is without even considering the libertarian/laissez-faire/capitalist alternative to Rawlsian justice as represented by the likes of Nozick and Rand, a position that a know-nothing would not be prepared to argue against intelligently or fairly.)