Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Dem & GOP impeachment hypocrisy to be revealed next week?

Or: intellectual honesty vs. political partisanship

(Context: 1, 2)

I don't know whether Trump's actions with respect to Ukraine and investigating Joe and Hunter Biden's Burisma-related dealings (qua point man on Ukraine for the Obama Admin, and not just qua potential 2020 political rival as the dishonest anti-Trump fake news would have you believe) amounts to an impeachable offense.  This is why I eagerly look forward to next week's progression of "the House impeachment inquiry" to the Judiciary Committee, where apparently constitutional experts will give the American People some testimony on what is a high crime or misdemeanor.  We can then find out whether the two major political parties are being consistent in their application of the rules.  A bonus feature of the next week's hearings will be committee Republicans grilling the witnesses about cases such as Clinton, Nixon, Obama, Reagan, et al.  Some questions these experts should help us to answer:


  • How are Trump's actions similar to or different from those of Presidents Clinton (who was impeached by the House but not removed by the Senate) and Nixon (who avoided impeachment by resigning...)?  How does this scandal differ from a non-impeachment-level scandal such as, say, Iran-Contra?


  • How are Trump's actions qua "using the levers of power to gain an electoral political advantage" different from the following by Obama: (1) Having his IRS make it a lot more difficult for "tea party" groups to gain tax exempt status like any other such advocacy groups; (Obama said there was not a "smidgen of corruption" there, a claim belied by then- IRS director Lois Lerner invoking the Fifth in front of Congress.) (2) Telling Vlad Putin's aides (caught on a hot mic) that he would have more flexibility for whatever Russia-related dealings after the 2012 election; (3) Overseeing an intelligence investigation into a Trump campaign aide apparently on the basis of spotty information.  (The Dems are convinced, after all, that any action whereby a lever of power is used to gain an electoral advantage is impeachable, in Trump's case.  Are they consistent?)


  • Is it really more than Trump being Trump, including his causal relationship with the truth?  Trump was under the impression that Biden used aid funds for Ukraine as leverage to prevent a prosecutor from looking into Burisma (where his son appears quite strongly to have benefited from nepotism).  According to Trump it "sounds terrible to me."  Well, if it sounds terrible to him - whether or not he was misinformed by overexposure to the zealously partisan rantings of Hannity & Co. - then what would be unlawful about wanting it looked into, irrespective of whether the guy may be a political opponent?  (The question, then, is whether he would have brought up Biden if Biden weren't running in 2020.  But then we also have Trump milking his usual obsessions about 2016 in the phone call as well, with the Crowdstrike server thing and supposed or confirmed Ukrainian meddling in 2016.  So if we can't read Trump's mind, what do we conclude here, impeachment-wise?)  And what difference does it make to all this that, plausibly, Trump was looking for evidence that Ukraine would be serious about fighting corruption generally?


  • What's the evidence that Biden/Burisma was such a big deal to Trump, over and above his having mentioned it in the 7/25 phone call, that he was pressuring people this way and that, sending Rudy and others to home in on that specifically, and basically trying to recruit other government actors into his corruptly-intended plan?  (Basically, the sort of Watergate-related actions that Nixon was involving or trying to involve others in?)

  • Does it make a real difference whether Trump was asking for help from Ukraine on finding serious misdeeds/corruption by Biden, vs. asking Ukraine to manufacture dirt?  If there were real corruption there, wouldn't we all want to know about it, irrespective of who benefits electorally?  (The anti-Trump media which have done themselves no favors by pretty much completely squandering their objectivity and credibility, have used the phrase "dig up dirt".  Like, just make it up, or find something real?  The confusion dishonestly generated here may show up in polls, but I wouldn't expect the House GOP committee members or other reasonably skeptical folks to accept that characterization.) 
  • Does the evidence of wrongdoing need to be overwhelming and unambiguous before removing a president from office?  (Was Bill Clinton's wrongdoing, for which there was overwhelming and unambiguous evidence, and for which he was stripped of his law license, still not enough to be impeachable?  [See here for analysis on the latter.])  Is that standard met here?

2/3 of the Senate is needed to convict and remove the president; that would suggest the requirement of overwhelming public support commensurate with such a supermajority.  Clear and convincing answers to questions such as the above are necessary for public support to shift in the direction of conviction/removal, particularly as consistent with traditional constitutional practice.  51 percent of the country "supporting impeachment and removal" as of a couple weeks ago is not evidence of overwhelming public support commensurate with a Senate supermajority.

The Dems and their media enablers have squandered too much credibility at this point, from their behaviors during the Trump years alone (not the least of which were their shameful and reckless attempts to smear Brett Kavanaugh), for their interpretations of things to be taken at anything close to face value.

(Can people who recklessly smeared Kavanaugh be trusted to honestly carry out a judicial proceeding?  Sens. Biden, Harris, Sanders, and Warren believed Blasey Ford's not-believable testimony, hence believed Kavanaugh's guilt, either before all the facts/testimony were in [as in the case of Scumbag Harris, and Scumbags Gillibrand and Hirono], or even after all the testimony and sworn statements were in, including Leland Keyser and others' crucial debunking of Ford's "memory," and, not least of all, the fact that Ford and Kavanaugh were in different social circles and so their being anywhere together was highly improbable.  If you were accused of a crime, would you want the likes of Biden, Harris, Sanders, Warren, Gillibrand and Hirono on your jury?  The question should answer itself.  BTW, when yet another bullshit NYT story about an allegation against Kavanaugh surfaced a couple months ago, almost all of these people immediately tweeted in support of Kavanaugh's impeachment.  Biden, prudently, didn't tweet such support along with Harris, Sanders, Warren and also Mayor Pete and a couple obvious clowns now out of the '20 running.  IOW, with the exception of Biden, all of the poll-leading '20 Dems would impeach an office-holder even on the flimsiest of bases.  The flouting of judicial and epistemic standards here is severe/perverse enough that Biden almost surely emerges as the least-worst option of those named above, pretty much by default.)

The likes of AOC (and other manifestly foolish Dems) seem to have wanted to impeach Trump for pretty much anything, including "racism," from the get-go.  (If you still aren't convinced what an obnoxious little nitwit AOC is, check out her vocal fry with the word "racisuuuum" in this excerpt.)  They milked a Trump-Putin collusion narrative for ratings for two years until their time- and attention-wasting charade fell apart after the Mueller findings.  The reasonable presumption here is that they have partisan motivations and hold GOP people to a more unreasonably demanding standard than they hold their own.

The reasonable presumption about the GOP with respect to their political opponents is also the same.  Let's say that a left/Dem SCOTUS justice dies in the next calendar year, a presidential election year.  If Mitch McConnell & Co. decide, contrary to their stance in 2016, to go ahead with a SCOTUS confirmation process denied to Obama nominee Merrick Garland, then they will self-convict as partisan pieces of shit.  The Dems, in their own partisan-POS way, will jump on the partisan GOP POS the split second any such thing happens.  But they were the same people calling for Judge Garland to be given a chance, after having said back in 1992 that SCOTUS nominees should not be given a chance during a presidential election season.  So there.  Perhaps the only serious question at this point is which of the two sides is more of a partisan POS, which side has squandered more intellectual credibility than its opponents, etc.  Philosophy awaits.

Tuesday, November 26, 2019

Stoned thought re a kid with a smirk and an old guy banging a drum in his face



With my perhaps impressive command of content, I was able to bring this post up within about 5 seconds.  (How about you?)  (If you're at that link, you might as well have a look at the rest of the content produced in this blog in just one month, over on the right there - 39 mostly scintillating posts in January alone.  [Incidentally, that whole problem that leading '20 Demorat candidates have with fair epistemic and judicial process when it comes to their treatment of (claims made against) Brett Kavanaugh, still lingers and is still glaring to anyone with a clue.  Any seasoned investigator would be able to deduce that no such event is remotely likely to have taken place as some party attended by both Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey Ford.  The way that Sens. Warren, Biden, Sanders, and Harris in particular treated these claims is epistemically criminal and the attorneys among them know better.  Blasey Ford's account simply cannot be believed as true to fact, whatever she told a therapist some years ago.  Anyway, just how perverse does one's episteme and value-structure have to get, in order to treat Blasey Ford's accusation as remotely credible once all the sworn testimony has come in (not the least of which is Leland Keyser's, you Dem fuckheads)?  Such epistemic criminality, perversity and bankruptcy just doesn't happen all of a sudden; it has to be cultivated over a matter of years. I blame the intellectually atrophied culture of leftism generally, with its always crying racism, its cancel culture, its context-erasing vilifications, etc. being typical results.  See this blog's "leftist losers" tag for all the exhaustive details.])

So, what it all really was, in the end, was a kid smirking and a buy banging a drum and chanting up in his face.  The MAGA hat really was entirely incidental, and the Native American ancestry completely irrelevant to the kid's reaction to what this man was doing in front of his face.  Basically, what the kid did according to today's insane "politically correct" leftists is commit a facecrime, from which they could interpret, rorschach-blotch-test-like, anything they damn well pleased (and they know, deep down, is exactly the dishonorable thing they are doing).  They do this all the time with Trump's pronouncements; on Day 1 of his political career, he said something something Mexico not sending its best and that it sends crime and drugs (e.g. opioids) and perhaps even some great people, and the Left immediately assumed the worst and has kept it up from then onward, really pathetic.  Speaker Peloser said repeatedly that his border wall idea is categorically an immorality because it's about Making American White Again, when plain reading and ordinary common sense says it's about keeping criminals out, since the only people the wall would keep out would be those trying to enter illegally/unvetted, and the Demorats are rightly perceived as soft on illegal immigration (and their political motivations are rightly called into question, especially when it involves a level of dishonesty and demagoguery like Peloser's about the border wall).

The incident between the smirking kid and the banging drum guy had nothing to do with America's racial and ethnic tensions (like one big happy semi-dysfunctional American family or something, more or less, right?), but with a kid reacting as any kid might normally react in such an increasingly bizarre situation that it was.  To make it in any way about race or ethnicity (on its face or otherwise) is to be an absolute fucking idiot with no business being near a viral or mass media outlet.  This goes for the relevant scumbags over at CNN, among other supposedly "center-"-left race-, sex-, gender-, ethnicity-. class-, etc.-baiting scum (more or less in lockstep with the likes of AOC+3) who've inundated the Demorat Party with their anti-intellectual, anti-philosophy, anti-wisdom, anti-Western-civ . . . does "nonsense" even dignify it?  Too much of it is already entirely false to fact (e.g., notions that capitalism is a fundamentally unfair or harmful economic system; see this blog's "capitalism" tag for all the juicy essentials).

Anyway, I'm sure that unlike the typical leftist slobs at D.C. events, the MAGA boys didn't leave trash behind.  Not so sure about that guy chanting and banging his drum in a kid's face.

Addendum: so how long before this shit is legalized everywhere?  FFS, already.

Monday, November 25, 2019

A bit of stoned blogging re Battle of the Billionaires


^_^

So I happen to know certain things (I've got information, man) about the "professional wrestling" industry (from which McMahon made his billion(s?)).  I happen to know that Trump happens to know what is or isn't fake, hence his constant and consistent use of the term "fake news."  (The whole thing where he "said" that Charlottesville neo-Nazis were "very fine people" and that either he never explicitly repudiated at least 3 or 4 different forms of "far right" racist groups or his very repudiations must have been a dog whistle, somehow, is essentially nothing more than a fabrication of a fevered leftist media.  You can look this all up, google is your friend.)  So Wrestlemania 4 (1988) was held at Trump Plaza, where there was this fake wrestling "tournament" (all in the span of 4 hours, mind you, and you'd think Macho Man Savage and Million Dollar Man DiBiase would be absolutely spent by the final fake-title-match...), where the Hulkster (Chump Hogan, as Jesse the Body always called him) used a chair when the referee was "knocked out" to knock DiBiasi out and win the title for his then-buddy Macho Man (the Mega Powers the duo would be called...).  This, mind you, all after Hogan fake-lost the title the previous month or so to Andre the Giant through a whole shenanigan involving a fake referee who was a not-fake identical twin of the real referee (and on the pay by Million Dollar Man, to whom Andre was just going to give the title he won right away to Million Dollar Man; then-WWF "president" Jack Tunny decided the most "fair" solution to this whole dirty trick once inevitably exposed is to vacate the WWF heavyweight title and have a tournament - all in one day, all within a 4-hour span - for the belt at, you guessed it, Wrestlemania; it's all quite believable to a credulous preteen audience of that certain time period before all the fakeness was exposed for sure at last...).

So, after about the time that Hogan fake-lost the WWF heavyweight title "fairly for the first time" to Ultimate Warrior in what was otherwise an epic-ly billed WM 6 (1990) face-off between two truly iconic figures of fake wrestling - it's basically up there by that point in time with the WM 3 (1987) battle between Hulk and Andre the Giant.  (I guess the idea there was for Andre to "lose" the match in a gesture of good will or whatever for the profession or the company, handing the torch much as Hulk would do himself at WM 6....)  (Also, let's not forget that the venue for WM3 was the Pontiac Silverdome with a crowd of over 90,000, setting some kind of record for like an indoor venue or something.  I just remember this kind of shit, somehow.... :-/ )

Then fast forward about 20 years to WM 23 (2007), and there's this "Battle of the Billionaires" between Trump and WWF/E founder Vince McMahon.  As you can see above, Trump ends up shaving McMahon's head while McMahon "protests."  It's all staged, all faked, of course.  But by then, the staged/kayfabe thing itself became part of the whole WWE shtick in a meta/ironic/satire way; it's all more like a stage play at this juncture with real life people "acting" for a crowd the role of heel/face/turn/troll/etc.

Anyway, come 2020, another Battle of the Billionaires may take place, and it might not be so staged/fake/kayfabe this time around.  "Little Mike" Bloomberg, as the mini-Billionaire said of the $50B man, has jumped all into the race.  I may have to eat my words from earlier this year about Trump being a guaranteed victor in the 2020 election since at the time Mike B had said he had no plans to run.  (I'll let the differently honest context-erasing fake-oppo dig up that post, where they'll also find an inductively compelling bundle of links, all taken together proving beyond a doubt the intellectual bankruptcy of the American Left.  June or July of this year is that post.)

Now, one thing that a philosopher armed with (a) a general knowledge of the whole fake-wrestling/kayfabe/acting thing that Trump's been involved in (did I mention he's in the WWE Hall of Fame? Not in this post I hadn't...), and (b) with a reasonably good working knowledge of the American national political system and scene over the last quarter century or so, must do is to determine all of the relevant differences between one "kind" of (scripted, dramatized, fake/not true to fact) Battle of the Billionaires and another.  To identify all relevant differences one would have to also have a good way of identifying relevant similarities, whatever those might be (beyond the similarity of there being two billionaires "cast" against one another).  And integrating and differentiating so, a philosopher might also have a pretty fun time, and perhaps even more fun of a time doing so while enjoying whatever creativity boosting substances one might find.

[Gotta take another hit, hold on.]

(in the meantime, ponder also the Schiff-Lebowski connection.  Evidently Schiff believes the prick is stonewalling him.)

Okay, I am thinking of how to liken and differentiate late-1980s WWF matchups from late-2010s presidential matchups.  As far as billionaire net worth is concerned, Mike Bloomberg is in the top 8 or so, so think the tier of WWF wrestlers who were in the "main event" of the first (1987) Survivor Series, maybe?  Well, only about 5 of those top-tier guys are really memorable; this would include (for sure) Hulk, Andre, (likely) King Kong Bundy, Bam Bam Bigelow, Ravishing Rick Rude (pretty great qua heel personality, as well as being totally ripped), (maybe) One Man Gang and Mr. Wonderful Paul Orndorff.  But top 5 or 8 is only a number; what's the proper adjustments?  There were maybe a few dozen "star" wrestlers at any one time (including tag teams), and perhaps up to 10 or 12 superstars (the 1987 Survivor Series tier-2 undercard included such superstars as Macho Man, Jake "The Snake" Roberts, Brutus "The Barber" Beefcake, Hacksaw Jim Duggan, and Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat (and the Honky Tonk Man was the Intercontinental Champion at the time, and I know who he lost it to in like 12 seconds hee hee . . .).  So what's the comparable population, the top few dozen billionaires with like 10 or 12 "superstars" which would include most likely Bezos, Gates, Buffett, and . . . Bloomberg?  But there are like at least a few hundred billionaires in the USA alone.  In the WWF you had in addition to the superstars and stars the "jobbers," the weak wrestlers with no stage personality to speak of who may not even ever appear in more than a match or two; the jobbers are basically there for the stars/superstars to showcase their skills against, although the superstar-against-jobber action was pretty limited, of course.  Let's just say that the jobbers aren't part of the regular rotation, but the numbers still seem a bit off here using a raw numbers-vs-numbers comparison.

What if we try out comparing the population of the few dozen stars/superstars in WWF in 1987 with the population of US billionaires?  The ratio is something like, roughly, 10 to 1?  And Bloomberg is in like the top 3% of the few hundred or so U.S. billionaires?  So the top 3 percent of WWF stars is basically the heavyweight champion himself.  (We have to take into account the fact that the wrestling talent that year was also spread out across wrestling associations.  In 1987 the key superstar in the biggest non-WWF wrestling association was (of course? the legendary?) Ric Flair.  Sooner or later they'd all basically merge, or something.  (I lost track not long after WM6 and then Warrior "losing" the title not long after.  All I know is, 13 years later there was the Battle of the Billionaires.)

So Trump's net worth is legitimately/documentably something like $5 billion.  He boasts that his brand name itself is worth (an additional) $5 billion on top.  (Is that a heel move?  What would the Million Dollar Man - a pretty memorable heel character, BTW - do?)  So that's in, what, like, the top half of U.S. billionaires, I might plausibly guesstimate?

That's assuming that measured net worth is the criterion on which to compare the "cards" here.

As far as heel stuff goes, the American Left does indeed have its heel figure in Trump, although that's mainly their problem since they're so deranged these days.  (These are the same losers who treat Ayn Rand as a heel figure - Scumbag Duggan's 'Mean Girl' is the best/worst smear effort the left could come up with in all of 6 decades after Atlas; pathetic.)

I do like how this will throw the Demorats into a bit of disarray.  Doesn't the existence of billionaires basically victimize the bottom 99%, or something?  Are the less deranged/corrupted among them ready to examine more carefully the whole value-added-by-billionaires thing as they possibly end up explicitly or implicitly rating Mike B higher because of the rare-skills value-added generated by someone whose net worth is about ten times higher than his opponent's.  (No doubt some hack-level MSDNC types are forming a wealth/skills narrative in their heads that conveniently fits with their possible Bloomberg-over-Trump narrative, seeing as they will also regard center-left politics as the view espoused by the more highly skilled people [unaccountably disregarding the libertarians as MSDNC hacks can be expected to do, of course].)

Trump says that Mike B would be the man he'd love running against the most.  Now, Mike B got into this race because he rightly suspects that the non-Bloomberg crop of Demorat candidates don't have what it takes to beat Trump.  The Demorat Party has (perhaps inevitably) let itself become beholden more than ever to a far-leftist-loser constituency and the public sector unions, giving the "moderates" like Biden that much harder of a time landing the nomination unless they shift their positions leftward.  And I think there may be a good chance that the gradually dwindling number of non-insane Dems and lefties end up seeing the merits in his view that he's probably the only one who could beat Trump in the general election.  (If he does become the nominee, then pretty much all but the staunch anticapitalist radical-left losers will rally around the "less-worse" non-Trump candidate.)  Given his wealth, can his doing an independent run for the office be ruled out?  (See, Ross Perot was the first billionaire [I think] to run for president (1992), and at the time his net worth was maybe like $1.8B, which was a much bigger deal back then.  He gets 19% of the vote, even after a mid-election-year flake-out....)

Anyway, what possible connection is there between Trump's asking Little Mike to bring it on, and the imagery/promotion related to a Battle of the Billionaires that must have been going through his head all this time?  Given his entertainment background, his mindset is only all that much more prepared for the concept.  Exactly how, I don't know.  It couldn't hurt his being prepared, could it?

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

A bit of stoned blogging about FISA abuse / Saddam WMDs

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/10-guy

I suppose we could file this under the general heading of either "Epistemology: human error/shortcomings" or "Ethics: virtue and vice: malice aforethought" or a bit of both . . .

So the "best intelligence" ca. early 2003 told us that Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein had active WMD programs.  Secretary of State Colin Powell went before a UN assembly and made a case for this and everything.  Trillions in treasure and many thousands of lives directly affected or ended.  Some say "Bush lied, people died."  Trump even said it boldly and clearly in a 2016 GOP primary debate (my jaw almost dropped, but by that point Trump had said any number of bold and crazy things (kill the families of terrorists, e.g.), only to treat them and many others as the high-end ("art of the deal" stuff here, I think/guess/ass-u-me) opening proposition, something provocative to float out there, all TrumpSpeak-like, only to draw back on the rhetoric when a better (more Trump-opinion-centric) political equilibrium is the achieved new focus.  (Trump's main point about the borders and the drugs etc. flowing across the southern border is about the need to secure our borders better; his initial July 2015 announcement rhetoric, as politically unpolished as it had to have been, (ffs, are Dems this stupid?...), is taken by the Dems/left as dead-to-rights evidence of "Trump's anti-Mexican, anti-immigrant racism," and then Trump wins the election on the actual issue (border/national security, the drug overdose crisis that basically won him the WI/PA/MI battleground states based on the latest research from somewhere on the interwebs doing all the properly adjusted statistical regressions, supposedly...).  (Here's a clue to Dems: The best chance you have of beating Donald Trump in 2020 is not to be so vile yourselves, so first on the order of business for cleaning up your act and getting into high gear is (a) study philosophy (a1) thoroughly and carefully; and (b) actually learn other ideas besides leftist ones so you can actually debate them better, and not be such loathsome losers otherwise, as they are especially when it comes to libertarians and especially Rand.  But they're also vile when it comes to Trump, immediately assuming the worst (i.e., racism) whenever Trump says any of his outlandish things that might possibly be interpreted by someone not in the target/intended audience as some kind of "dog whistle" (as Trump must have been using the word "lynching"; just ask Uncle Joe, he "knows" it for a fact...the doddering old fool...?)  So anyway, Trump said that Bush lied us into the Iraq War, but Colin Powell presented the Best Intelligence Available at The Time.  So was it incompetence in the intelligence community, a bit of lying by actors within the intelligence and/or political community, or a bit of both?  Were "intelligence findings" basically selectively twisted for political and perhaps (gasp) partisan-political ends?

And so, when it comes to that FISA court application to spy on Trump aide Carter Paige in late 2016 which the leftist media & ilk/enablers have been studiously evading awareness about, all the while they pursue for countless hours a Russia/Trump collusion conspiracy narrative for 2 and a half years instead of waiting for the Mueller Report (to find nothing collusion-wise...so Adam Schiff-show is a doddering younger fool, yes? ... and if you turn the party-affiliation tables, what Trump did in his "favor" phone call (7/25; Never Forget) is comparable impeachment-wise to, what, Obama's hot-mic "favor" of Vlad Putin in light of Barry's greater flexibility after the elections.  But Schiff-show's job is not intellectual honesty, it's basically as a shield for Peloser who could be less of a Peloathsome Peloser by starting with steps (a, a1 & b) above).  So, now, we are asked to believe by apologists for the, let's just call it for the moment the DEEP STATE (spooky music, etc.), and/or even some of the very same people who vilified the intelligence/Bush43 Admin for its quote unquote intelligence failures over Iraq/WMD, that - get this - the Steele Dossier was credible and well-founded enough to use as a key basis for the FISA application.

OR . . . the so-called quote unquote intelligence officials - the best and the brightest, the state of the art people, etc. so we were told - were not so pure in their motivations and so were willing to cut ethical and perhaps legal corners if that meant something that might at least kneecap a man they believe(d) to be a dangerous figure national security-wise.  (What, was Machiavelli the only political philosopher they remember from their Best and Brightest University Survey Course?  Presumably they never bothered to cover Aristotle and they - again, presumably - missed the point of Plato's Republic.  [Wait, so that particular utopia sounds too demanding for mere mortals, so might as well give up on the idea of utopia?  Is that where Aristotle went with Plato's message?  Let's ask the Best and Brightest.  Speaking of the Best and Brightest, I assume Socrates and Aristotle qualify.  So, Socrates, having failed to convince his fellow Athenians of the value of his philosophical services, submits to their (unjust...or is it, since they haven't been rationally persuaded?) verdict and punishment, which is death.  This man whom we might take to be supremely wise accepts the verdict of his fellow citizens, however ignorant and vicious it might be.  They found Socrates irritating, let's say, or perhaps a threat to any number of powerful people who thrive power-wise on poor public opinion formation.   Anyway, Socrates put his life at the polis' disposal, quite un-libertarian-like, if you ask me, but this is a man thought to be supremely wise in the face of death and everything, so his opinion should be heard out, thoroughly and carefully.  The life of a philosopher - perhaps even a sage - was at stake.  At any rate, the products which he did not live himself to see where the schools run by Plato and Aristotle.  Aristotle's body of work is the crowning achievement of humanistic learning in ancient Greece.  Now, Aristotle was tudor to Alexander the Great, who by a relatively very young age conquered much of the then-known world before dying, and some kind of anti-Alexander backlash back in Athens made Aristotle unsafe doing business there, and so he left to some other part of Greece, Macedonia, whatever, his parting shot to Athens being something to the effect of, "...lest Athens sin twice against philosophy."  So there.)

So that "Steele Dossier" (which should in all transparency be identified as the Glenn Simpson/Fusion GPS/paid for by Hillary Clinton Steele Dossier) garnered a whole lotta attention within that very same(?) United States Intelligence Community, and officials even swore under oath to the FISA court that this was well-vetted information, this Simpson/Fusion/Clinton/Steele Dossier.

So I find it interesting if not intriguing if not fascinating in its own right - and I think all the American People possessing so much as an ounce of intellectual curiosity should find it likewise - that this now-discredited document full of Russian [i.e. Putin? the grandmaster? the man who evaded pointed questions from Chris Wallace more thoroughly than anything I've ever seen, I mean, after one of Putin's answers in that interview I didn't know whether he had me coming or going, the man is a grandmaster of obfuscation, I credit him with that.] lies, was treated by all the high-level Intelligence Community Officials as not only credible enough to warrant a bunch of attention but well-supported enough to be used as a key basis to obtain a FISA warrant.  All under Obama's where-the-buck-stops watch, too.

To restate the point more succinctly and directly: This phony "Steele dossier," full discredited and unreliable smears, was attested to as a reliable-enough document by Obama high-up DEEP STATE officials, to be used as a basis for a FISA warrant.  Wow.

So, either:
How easy is it to fool the American Intelligence Community?
or:
Can politically-appointed high-ups in the American Intelligence Community be trusted to act in good faith when questionable "information" comes their way?

(Hillary Clinton gets caught in a similar logical bind when it comes to her whole "email thing."  She said "she's sorry for that," and then pivots as fast as possible to another topic, but what would contrition mean here, Hillary?  So maybe, just maybe, you didn't break the law with that whole unauthorized-by-State server and the mishandling of the 110 duly classified documents (you even bullshitted the American People about that? Pathetic.), but what are the logical consequences here, Ms. Clinton?  Explain to the American People how someone who did what you did should be granted a security clearance at any point thereafter.  If Comey were forthright in his July 2016 press announcement and testimony, he would have been specific that this behavior would disqualify anyone from having a security clearance, whether or not laws were broken.  But that's Comey for you, I guess.  He assures us he's all on the up and up, scout's honor, etc.  Plus that whole meeting between Crooked Bill and Crooked Loretta Lynch on the tarmac didn't look good even by Swamp ethical standards, so he had to intervene, supposedly.)

(The high has mostly worn off by now.)

In the hopper: considerations of the thesis/theme that the more philosophical a life the more eudaimonic it is, or some variation of that idea, and that one cannot have eudaimonia (certainly not full or complete eudaimonia, if that differentiation can be applied here, that is, if eudaimonia is not something complete by definition) without one's life being philosophically organized and engaged.  In brief question form it's: Is eudaimonia possible without at least some amount of heavy-duty philosophical activity?  And philosophy here specifically means theoretical contemplation (toward and from first principles, etc.) as distinct from (merely) the love or pursuit of practical wisdom or phronesis.  This is the pursuit of sophia, i.e. theoretical wisdom.  So can one have a complete conception of eudaimonia without engaging in philosophy to identify the nature of eudaimonia, be able to identify instances, etc.?  And can one be eudaimonic without having a complete conception of eudaimonia?

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

A bit of stoned blogging about Better Living Through Philosophy / End of History


(this is all from one hit, mind you, plus a bunch of stuff accumulated over decades right here in this stoned noggin)

An idea that keeps re-occuring to me as I get stoned and admire/examine my really nicely-stocked physical (and digital) library: One possible(-world) humorous subtitle for my in-development Better Living Through Philosophy book is something along the lines of:

or, 100 essential books condensed into one

First off, the value-added if this were pulled off as represented would be really high for one book...

So the monetary angle aside for the moment, and looking at this from a theoretical-philosophical-moral angle with all the implications involved . . .

It has a certain similarity to what the venerable 20th century philosopher-public-intellectual Mortimer J. Adler was doing with what is arguably his magnum opus, Great Ideas: A Lexicon of Western Thought, which is more or less a 960 page, double-column synthesis of the (Western) wisdom of the ages contained in the famous Great Books series of which he was the chief architect/curator/commentator.  So at the very least I would like to approach something similar to what Adler is doing in just that one book.  For the average reader/citizen, just that one book is arguably a godsend from the condensed-value-added standpoint.  For yours truly, it was more or less an edification or beefing up of a bunch of stuff I had already integrated, book-smarts-wise plus lots of attentive cultural observation, over the course of decades.  Also, if I could condense what Adler was doing down to something more like 420 single-column book, it would be that much more value-added-wise.  Thing is, Adler's magnum opus is not even in print any more; you have to buy it in a used marketplace somewhere, or find it at a local library.  It belongs in every learned person's personal library, anyway.  I have it in mine; it's like a no-brainer, that one.  Is it in yours?

If it's in mine and not yours, that's one distinct research-advantage I have over you.  And I use it now as as source of inspiration for how to compose an epic, sprawling, magisterial and fun - above all, fun - book on the subject of Better Living Through Philosophy.  And that's just the tippy top of the iceberg when it comes to books in my personal library to draw inspiration from.  Now to induce whatever principle is involved here:

I have selected a few hundred of what I regard as essential books for Any Learned Person to Have on Hand, for my personal library.  I've had to be somewhat selective in what I have been able to purchase and make room for, but I think I have developed a really strong sense, over decades of experience, for what is a promising, uh, lead when it comes to various things cultural and intellectual.  It doesn't mean I know a ton of shit about a ton of shit.  (One promising beginning lead here, though, might be the New York Times Guide to Essential Knowledge, which I have on hand.  Do you? . . .)  It does mean, though, that I am probably the very best researcher that I know of.  I fucking love what I have in my personal library (paper and digital...) and I especially love how I have it so nicely organized.  How do I have it organized, you ask?  Well, isn't that something of a trade secret, if you will?  Do I just wanna give it away, right here?  I've told a few close friends about how I have it organized.  If a Resurrected-Aristotle were to organize his library nowadays, on what sort of principle might he organize it?  How are libraries proper organized, pray tell?  What comes first?...  (I've given this subject a lot of thought.  Have you?)

Then I have about a dozen Oxford Handbooks (you know what those are, right?) in my physical library (they're kinda pricey...).  Do I have any in my digital library?  Well, do I?  You tell me.

I really find Oxford Handbooks quite useful, most of the time.  So I'm able to distinguish more useful Oxford Handbooks from less useful ones.  How about you?

So I've got Adler's Lexicon and then I also have the (out-of-print as well) Adler-edited Great Treasury of Western Thought.  A Resurrected-Aristotle would definitely have this one in his library, right?  (In the Academy, Aristotle garnered the nickname of 'The Reader,' BTW.  Books were definitely important to him.)

So one thing Aristotle (in a manner similar to Adler, but perhaps different) might do or consider doing in composing a treatise on the subject of Better Living Through Philosophy is to, more less, take the reader/audience on a guided tour of essential (Western-intellectual-tradition) books for a learned citizen.

So, what selection criteria would Aristotle use to narrow down his selection of essential titles through which to usefully take his audience on that guided tour?  I don't know, actually; I'm not Aristotle, after all.  I'm me.  And I have some idea of either what my selection criteria are or of the product of my selection criteria.  So in my list of top-100 essentials I would have those two big Adler books I've mentioned, probably a number of Oxford Handbooks (the more useful ones, anyway), and then, letsee, I have the Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy (both 1st and 2nd editions) on hand.

But maybe that's all the leads I'm gonna give on that subject in this post.  I already have a shit-ton of promising leads already on this blog.  I know where to go to find 'em just in case.  I know when I "reviewed" Norton's Personal Destinies on this blog.  I have quick recall of a lot of destructive-leftism-related links just in case the need to prove my point yet again about destructive leftism arises (yet again, sigh).  (BTW, those losers-qua-leftists up on stage last night were going on and on about Better Living Through Big Government.  They just don't get it, do they.  Would Resurrected-Aristotle-in-Drill-Sergeant-Mode tear them a new one, or what?  [Edit: How about this, which I'm not sure the leftists would ever figure out on their own in a million years: Better Social Capital Through Philosophy.  Eh?  Eh? {Edit: Is a warranted induction on the principle here expressed as follows: Better x Through Philosophy, where x could stand for any number of desirable things?  Ya think?}])

So anyway, I think I know (about) a ton of promising leads on certain important End-of-History related subjects.  (You know all about what 'End of History' refers to, right?  I've given this subject more than a teensy bit of thought over the years, mind you.)  That doesn't mean I know (about) a ton of leads on a ton of shit.  I couldn't tell you who won the Kentucky Derby in 1963.  I do know that Wilt Chamberlain was NBA MVP in his rookie season but not the season he averaged 50 points a game and scored 100 in one of them.  Now who in the fuck would have beaten Wilt out for the MVP award that year?  I know.  Do you?)

So the one hit is starting to wear off, the magic inevitably to wear off as well.  Now I've got the munchies.

[Addendum 10/16 (un-stoned): I'm sure getting a lot of emails from academia.edu with links to papers closely connected to the topic of Aristotle's intellectualist conception of eudaimonia lately; how about you?  I don't know/remember how this turned out to be the case, but it's not a bad subject to get a lot of academia.edu emails about, is it?  What would be more perfect a topic to get such emails/papers about?]

Monday, October 14, 2019

Some good stuff

I have (of course) noticed that many of my posts of late have been political-polemical.  Here are some positives:

Coleman Hughes, black undergraduate philosophy major at Columbia, making any number of eminently admissible arguments about race issues which it appears (here come the polemics again...) the American left is neither prepared nor has the good faith to take on.  If he's right, then the American left has been shitting the bed for long enough that even a single undergrad philosopher can run circles around them, more or less.  Nothing that I've seen in the comments sections of his articles (I went through the entirety of the comments for this one, just to see...) would suggest that the American left has much in the way of rebuttals that would make any reasonable and duly informed person think that the American left has anything like a monopoly on good arguments on race issues.  (Much as with the Trump-Clinton election, the American left would have you think that it's some kind of knock-down, not-even-a-close-call argument in favor of the leftist viewpoint on this and a wide range of other issues.)  I did google 'criticism rebuttal response to coleman hughes' and the search returned all of one result of any usefulness, also a thoroughly admissible entry into the discussion.  However...

In the course of reading a number of Hughes-related posts, I encountered this article, "Why Does Racial Inequality Persist? Culture, Causation, and Responsibility," by Glenn Loury, and it is about as thoughtful and humane an article as I've ever seen on the subject of America's Racial Problem.  But it is most certainly not a leftist article - and it's the kind of article that I would be surprised to find the left having the courage, integrity, honor, good faith, etc., to take on (which would require admitting that the left, by narrowing its focus to only certain causal factors, has been shitting the bed for decades).  So basically it's either-or: Either Hughes and Loury (and numerous other often-black conservatives who've studied and written about this topic indepth) have eminently admissible arguments, in which case the American left has been shitting the bed, Or the American left's MO has been reasonable, normal, dialectically accountable, honorable, etc.  Take your pick.

Hughes and Loury are, in effect, throwing down the glove to issue this challenge: "Okay, leftists, let's do talk about the legacy of Jim Crow and redlining and ongoing systemic injustices.  And you, lefties - you get to address the problem of the sky-high rate of single-parent families in the black community.  Deal?"  Concerted silence/evasion in the face of this offer/challenge is what I expect from the American left.  (Implicitly contained in the challenge is what I've alluded to above: that the American left acknowledge how badly it's been shitting the bed and make a hearty effort to prevent further bed-shitting.  I don't expect that to be forthcoming any time soon, i.e., I would be rather surprised - pleasantly so - if that were to happen.)

On to another positive, without the polemical implications this time (except those pertaining to the ecologically oblivious/their enablers...):

I recently read The River Why by David James Duncan, which I spotted on a home bookshelf.  It's both fun and thought-provoking, and made an impression that books rarely do for me.  (A few other titles of lasting interest for me: Mises, Socialism; Letters of Ayn Rand and The Romantic Manifesto; Norton, Personal Destinies; Nozick, The Examined Life; Rasmussen and Den Uyl, Liberty and Nature; Gewirth, Self-Fulfillment.)  Then again, I'm not especially well-read when it comes to books and I'm not a particularly fast reader; for building my reading list I have to use my sense of quality/importance over the pursuit of quantity.  As for The River Why, one might get a good sense of its qualities from the goodreads users' reviews.  I just wanted, at the least, to provide a pointer in its direction (just in case I kick the bucket before the next blog posting, etc.).

Saturday, October 12, 2019

Demo rats as a/the new Stupid Party


(context)

From a facebook timeline:
"For decades I have chuckled with Democrats about the astounding idiocies of the Stupid Party. Now that the Democracy has taken on that dubious mantle, I sure would like to chuckle with the Republicans for a change. Alas, this is tricky, seeing as how the GOP has not lost its Stupid Party standing by getting any wiser."
It's not just Trump/Republicans/right-wingers saying this stuff, folks.  The intellectual meltdown of the American left both before and after Trump is not only (sadly) the real thing, but is becoming increasingly obvious to those with a clue.  Gone are the days of Daniel Patrick Moynihan, i.e., of maintaining some intellectual quality control and of checking leftward drift (which come to the same thing...).  Not only that, the Dems, who dominate the institutions of "education," have that much less of an excuse for becoming such a pitiful spectacle.

[Addendum 10/16: Many members of this new Stupid Party use up quite a bit of valuable brain space and talking energy informing everyone that "Hillary won the popular vote," making no mention of the fact that neither Trump nor Clinton bothered to campaign in states like CA.  Do these numbskulls really believe that Trump wouldn't have gained in popular vote totals if he campaigned in CA more?  Can they not accept the fact that (a) there is wisdom in the Electoral College format; and (b) Trump simply out-campaigned Clinton in the crucial swing states?  Clinton's failure to even step foot in WI is her own responsibility regardless of whom she chooses to blame; the bum lost.  The only thing her attempt to shift blame/responsibility does, is to reinforce the impression that Demo rats are the type to shift blame for their own failings so as to justify higher taxes on the 'winners' and using the proceeds to subsidize failure.]

Friday, October 11, 2019

Trump vs. fake news, in a nutshell

"That is a lot of fake news back there."

Trump: "Fake news is the enemy of the American people."

Fake news: "Trump says a free press is the enemy of the American people."

Either you get what's going on here, or you might just be clueless/a Democrat.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

Why are Trump/GOP assholes re LGBT+ rights?


If there's anything the GOP obviously has a poor track record on, it's LGBT+ rights.  (Another would be too much blindness to real racial injustices, and that includes their hypocritical support for (predictably?) failed big-government "drug-war" policies that have disparate racial impacts.  Not that this vindicates the left all that much; they're the ones hypocritically pointing out the failures of big-government policies in only this one area, immediately crying racism whenever an "unarmed black teenager" is killed by police (e.g.), etc.)

From what reporting I've been seeing, the Trump administration is arguing in front of the Supreme Court against standard Civil Rights protections for LGBT+ people.  Here's something I find revealing in this context: while there's no shortage of Fox News links on any number of Google News topics, there aren't any on this subject, not on the first two pages of results, anyway.  If Fox News isn't reporting on it, chances are good that the activities involved are really too shameful for them to direct its audience's attention that way and to really air the Cultural-Political Right's laundry on this.

The Congress is chock-full of selectively attentive cowards who refuse to do the right thing when it comes to (a) ending federal cannabis prohibition (consider, e.g., the callousness and willful cluelessness involved toward medical cannabis users), and (b) updating the Civil Right act to include the same protections for LGBT+ people.  These are such no-brainer issues that it's not hard to figure out what the "right side of history" position is.  (Although see my tentatively-proposed position as a libertarian below.)  And it's GOP politicians who (on average, of course) are more toxic on these issues than those across the aisle.  (It's just too bad that the Demo rats bring so much credibility-destroying toxicity to just about any issue; see below, for example, on their anti-libertarian attitudes toward Christian bakers.  And good luck getting them to couch their arguments for weed legalization in the language of freedom rather than racial equity or [their perennial addiction] tax revenues.)  While it's believable that a Democrat-controlled Congress would do the right thing on these issues at some point in the not-distant future, I have a hard time believing that a GOP-controlled Congress would ever get around to doing so (unless they faced severe political repercussions for their shameful inaction).  [Edit: on a related note, would states like Texas ever have gotten around to repealing their sodomy laws (which are premised on the patently evil idea that people's lives are the state's and not their own to dispose of) on their own accord, absent SCOTUS intervention?]

If it were merely about the right of a baker to refuse baking a cake for a same-sex wedding, then we have an apparent clash of deep constitutional values.  (I say it's "apparent" because I don't see any warranted presumption that a business "open to the public" must do things that violate the religious convictions of the business-owner.  Also, the libertarian principle involved becomes more clear-cut when "bake my cake, bigot" morphs into "wax my balls, bigot.")  I don't see what clash of deep constitutional values is involved in the right of a business to fire someone on the basis of their sexual preference or gender identity when there are other relevantly-similar protected classes under prevailing law.  (Again as a libertarian, I say the presumption should be in favor of the right of a business to discriminate as long as it openly advertises its bigotry.  But I'm tentatively saying that it's a presumption, and that context matters in reasonably delimiting the scope of property rights.  No doubt some asshole business-owners would abuse this presumption to the maximal extent if given the chance....)

If you don't think anti-intellectualist, anti-liberal strains of religious dogma don't have something to do with this, then I would urge a look into attitudes toward LGBT+ rights in the Bible Belt.  Just because those attitudes aren't as shitty as they were a few decades ago, doesn't mean they still aren't shitty.

Have a look at Trump's shameful, anti-evidence behavior and policies (which go beyond the usual distractions associated with Trumpspeak) in this and some related areas.  Not only isn't he friendly toward LGBT+ rights as advertised, but he's also clearly blanket-Islamophobic. (From what I can tell, you might as well treat his and Pamela Geller's views on Islam as interchangeable).  (And while we might treat his 2016 campaign-season proposal to ban all Muslims entering the country as the usual casual-relationship-to-truth Trumpspeak which had little to zero chance of ever being implemented, along with his quickly-abandoned campaign-season proposals to kill the families of terrorists and bring back torture of terror suspects, the sentiment behind it is unquestionably Islamophobic.)  It isn't just a matter of the usual blustery things he says, but what he has done policy-wise.

And whether or not it affects his policy decision, when Trump contradicts himself from one time period to the next, as he has done most obviously on the cannabis-legalization issue, and doesn't explain himself, then that is evidence of bad faith and/or cynical pandering.  "It's just Trumpspeak" doesn't help when he unaccountably contradicts himself.  (Likewise, "Trump's saving grace is his ridiculous/unhinged/dishonest opposition," while quite arguably true, doesn't transform him into a non-asshole.)  (Likewise, one doesn't have to be one of these toxic-af radical trans activists - too toxic even for many on the "progressive" left - to recognize how transphobic and/or downright ignorant of transgenderism so many on the Cultural Right are; "God created two biological sexes" won't erase the distinction between sex and gender, for example.  How about this: there's plenty of toxicity to go around on this subject, coming from any number of directions.)

I'd just like to know, what these GOP people think is the upside to upholding (whether actively or by omission) the putative right of businesses to fire people for being gay, given their not upholding the right to do so in the case of biological sex, race, or religion.  And the philosopher's question: just how far, exactly, are they willing to go on this, before even they get ashamed and disgusted with themselves?  (My first philosopher's question for leftists would be: just how egregious, exactly, does a distortion or smear of Ayn Rand have to be, before even the leftists start calling foul?  They've been real lowlifes on this subject, as it is....)  Something specific, please.

[Addendum: An extension of the philosopher's questions: for those who aren't outright assholes, just how far, exactly, do their colleagues on their own side of the aisle have to go in being assholes, before the non-assholes start calling the assholes out?  (Or: how far, exactly, does the non-called-out asshole behavior have to go, before those failing to call out the assholes start becoming assholes themselves?  Something specific, goddammit.)]

[Addendum 10/12: Some common sense reasoning requiring little to no mental gymnastics in either (left/right) direction: Sexual orientation and gender identity are in the same category of 'immutable characteristics' that make sex, race, and religion protected classes under the Civil Rights Act.  How much, exactly, ahem does one need to read into the Civil Rights Act to see that it is about protected classes based on immutable characteristics and not only about those classes concretely enumerated in the Act?  Congress refuses to do the right thing here, after all....]

Tuesday, October 8, 2019

Trump: "My unmatched wisdom"

Apropros this tweet:

  1. As I have stated strongly before, and just to reiterate, if Turkey does anything that I, in my great and unmatched wisdom, consider to be off limits, I will totally destroy and obliterate the Economy of Turkey (I’ve done before!). They must, with Europe and others, watch over...


(1) A sage publicly touting his/her own wisdom is probably a contradiction in terms.

(2) Trumpspeak probably has its roots in WWE-style kayfabe and smack-talk.  If you don't get that, then you miss out on a lot of the dynamic between Trump and his fans.  (If you're an elitist you might tend to look down on both of these entertainment genres and their fans.)  (Incredibly enough, I didn't encounter a dropdown menu option for "trumpspeak" in google search.)  (Are Demo rats and leftists all too easily trolled by Trumpspeak?)  (Last but not least: is it wise for a POTUS to engage in WWE/kayfabe smack-talk regardless of whether some or all people are "in on the act"?  No, I don't think so; I think it indicates a degradation of the political, but a degradation rather commensurate with the intellectual bankruptcy of both our politics generally and of Trump's opposition especially; that is, Trump is more a symptom rather than cause, bringing the intellectual bankruptcy to the fore of everyone's attention in an undiluted, unapologetic fashion.  It's not the kind of shit you'd see Marcus Aurelius, an actual historical ruler-sage, engaging in.  Speaking of Trump's intellectually-bankrupt left-opposition, shouldn't the public-sector "educators" be all over the example of Marcus Aurelius like flies on shit, on the assumption that they want/need historical examples of non-intellectually-bankrupt politics to point to for inspiration/instruction?  If they're not all over that sort of thing - and it appears they're just somehow not interested - then ain't that just fucking ridiculous?  These are the people to whom the nation should be entrusting the next generation's education?  I mean, it's one thing for unionized public-sector employees to face perverse incentives, but just how fucking hard can it be, exactly, to learn and teach about Marcus Aurelius?  Or Plato and Aristotle, for that matter?  A philosopher's question: Just how bad does it have to be in this regard, before the People really begin finding this situation to be most unacceptable?  50% worse than it is now?  100%?  What's the breaking point; that's all I'd like to know.  And how can the "educators" really complain about having a Trump as president when they fail to know and teach about serious counterexamples?  It's not just Marcus Aurelius, either; all the key American Founders were seriously philosophical people, a fact which the "educators" seem to bury underneath such facts as the Founders having been slave-owners, say.)

Leftism's reverse-Midas effect: toxicity (e.g., "white privilege")

Following up my recent post on the "educators" indoctrinating their impressionable captive audience about "white privilege":

"White privilege" is an academic-leftist neologism that has not been run by the mainstream of America before the left foisted the notion on the rest of us.  I encourage readers to look at the wikipedia link on "white privilege" to see the notion explained.  From the introductory section:

White privilege (or white skin privilege) is the societal privilege that benefits white people over non-white people, particularly if they are otherwise under the same social, political, or economic circumstances. ...Writers have noted that the "academic-sounding concept of white privilege" sometimes elicits defensiveness and misunderstanding among white people, in part due to how the concept of white privilege was rapidly brought into the mainstream spotlight through social media campaigns such as Black Lives Matter.[9] As an academic concept that was only recently brought into the mainstream, the concept of white privilege is frequently misinterpreted by non-academics; some academics, having studied white privilege undisturbed for decades, have been surprised by the seemingly-sudden hostility from right-wing critics since approximately 2014.[10]
Again, I encourage a reading of the full wikipedia link, where what is explained as "white privilege" is advantages that whites (qua whites) experience relative to nonwhites in America.  The "advantages" enjoyed by whites are actually the effect of (real or contrived-by-leftists) unfair and unjust treatment of nonwhites.  In essence - and I'm doing my utmost to characterize this notion accurately - what the wikipedia link describes is a set of circumstances in which whites are not treated unfairly relative to nonwhites.

In essence, then, "white privilege" is whites not being treated unjustly.  No, it's not some special or acquired advantage, as the term "privilege" traditionally denotes (or is it connotes...).  It doesn't mean an advantage conferred, per se.  It means a disadvantage inflicted on others.  (And speaking of things that disadvantage black youth, does the greater prevalence of single-parent families among minorities and black people in particular also contribute to "white privilege"?  Should we double down and insist that this disparity is due to the white-privilege power structure, etc.?)

At this point you might understand how this notion would "elicit defensiveness and misunderstanding" among those upon whom the notion is foisted.  What is taken by the leftist authors of "white privilege" to be defensiveness and misunderstanding is really nothing more than disorientation and confusion as to how the term "privilege" is genuinely applicable to a situation in which what makes the "privileged" privileged is that they're not treated unjustly.  Instead of a term that conveys, commonsense-like, the unjust treatment of nonwhites, the leftists have decided that bastardizing altering the language is a preferable move.  (More examples of leftist language-alterations here.)  And you'd better go along with this alteration pretty darn quickly, lest you be complicit in perpetuating "white privilege."

I wish that there were something that I'm missing here, but I've given up on giving leftists the benefit of the doubt.

If the "white privilege" notion were an isolated thing, not intertwined with a bunch of leftist ideology, with a related cluster of neologisms and dogmas, etc., then one might reasonably treat it as an unfortunate inexactness, or a lapse in an otherwise cogent, good-faith critique of prevailing American institutions.  But that's not what this is.

I think leftism is toxic wherever it is found, but a thesis I'd like to advance in connection with this (the "white privilege" topic as well as all the other intellectual failings documented quite exhaustively in my leftism-related links) is as follows:

The American left is especially toxic and intellectually bankrupt, because of how at-odds leftism is with uniquely American founding and operating ideals, namely: freedom from state power.  The American left is set up starkly over-and-against the American mainstream, standing in a position (as it were) of dialectical alienation.  (This is why leftism seems to be a much "better fit" in European nations such as France, where (e.g.) the French Revolution of the late 18th century illustrates the contrast with America's revolution/break with the English Crown.)

A key example: the ideas of Ayn Rand are within a legitimate Overton Window of range of opinion in America.  There is a (relatively) healthy debate on the American Right over the role that Ayn Rand should play in forming culture and politics.  A great portion of the ideas in Atlas Shrugged resonate with a large segment of the Right (particularly the free-market, libertarian right).  How does the Left respond to Ayn Rand?  I'm speaking here of the American Left; the Left as well as non-Left in Europe don't treat Rand as being within the Overton Window of discourse there.  (Just how punitively high should taxes on the rich be, is the point in contention in these Euro-welfare-states.  Just how much someone should be able to keep what they earn through providing value-added to customers/purchasers in legitimately voluntary transactions, is the point of contention in the American mainstream.  Or: does your life fundamentally belong to you, or to the state/demos/collective?  And: is politics the most just, appropriate, humane, etc. way of addressing social problems?)

Returning to the question: how does the American Left treat or respond to Ayn Rand?  My very extensive experience with this is that these leftists do nothing more than misrepresent, distort, and smear Rand, when they're not ignoring or evading her message.  ("She would let the poor die in the gutter, since her heroes say their lives belong to themselves and not to the poor or govt agents purporting to act on their behalf."  And they choose to ignore the message from Galt about virtue-based aid to the unfortunate.  The leftist assumption here seems to be that if it isn't state-directed aid, it is too precarious and conditional to fit the requirements of justice.  That's an area for good-faith disagreement, not for unquestioned assumption.)

Given the founding and (still by and large - at a roughly 65% rate, anyway) operative principles of America, the legitimate Overton Window would be the range of opinion between Rawls and Nozick/Rand.  [Edit: And a Rawls vs. Nozick/Rand debate might not even take all that much into consideration the reasonably well-argued opinions of many of those describing themselves as conservatives, which pretty much makes it that much more difficult for the Left to defeat non-leftist opinion on the merits.]  But this is not what the American Left sees as the legitimate range of opinion.  The "center" of leftist opinion in America today is the more Euro-style "democratic socialism" of Bernie Sanders and AOC, with Rand/Nozick written off as terribly misguided, inhumane, evil, etc.  What else explains the absolutely pathetic way the American Left debates - i.e., avoids debating head-on, in good faith - rightist ideas (including those of conservatives/Republicans and Trump supporters in general)?

The American Left has replaced a good-faith dialogue with the American Right, with an ever-more-inbred debate about, e.g., how exactly to construct the "white privilege" notion, or just how racist Trump and his supporters are, or just how much more GDP should go to the public sector, or just how evil Rand is, or just how much illegal immigration should be incentivized, or just exactly which past American presidents and national symbols should be besmirched and boycotted, or just how exactly to blame capitalism for high healthcare costs, or just exactly how fundamentally unfair the capitalist system is, or just how exactly and how much to smear Brett Kavanaugh, or just how exactly to distort/smear/deplatform/cancel/evade what conservative opinion that does exist on college campuses, and on and on.

Is it any surprise, then, that the chief source of toxicity in American politics today is leftism, with the Trump phenomenon a backlash against that?

Here's another, related thesis: on the actual merits, many of the best political minds in America are on the Right.  The American Left, by virtue of an atrophied dialectical sensibility, is full of hubris - namely, the assumption that they possess a superior intellectual and moral compass (made more developed by proximity to big coastal cities and college campuses, apparently).  By their own lights this puts them at odds with an American mainstream full of irredeemable deplorables, racists, religious fundamentalists clinging bitterly to their Bibles/religion, rednecks clinging to their guns, etc.  Given their hubris, their outsized commitments to political activism (a substitute religion) as a source of meaning, and the roadblocks to their political vision presented by conservatives, libertarians, Republicans, Trump, talk radio, Fox News, the electoral college, and the Constitution as interpreted in good faith (i.e., with the strong presumption of liberty), it's no surprise that they come off as so miserable and nasty over not having gotten their way.

I would say that the problem has gotten only worse over time (and will continue to get worse) because of the irreconcilable opposition between leftism and America and the American left's doubling down on the correctness of leftism (with the complicitly of the "educators") in the face of this.

I won't belabor this further; either you see how I'm right (here and in all the other blog posts about leftism/leftists I have provided ample leads for above) or you don't.  If anything, this here blog post demonstrates that it's pretty much the end of the line as far as American-leftism's credibility is concerned; it serves more or less as a culmination of all those other blog posts.  This here blog post can and will serve well as a one-stop unit for future reference, whenever I mention how intellectually and morally bankrupt the American Left is.  (The further left you go, the more deranged and toxic it gets.)  Had they ever engaged in good faith with the likes of Rand I might have concluded differently.  If they were nearly as progressive and forward-looking as they pretend to be, they'd be gung-ho on philosophy and philosophical education.

As it is, my one-word summary of the American left is: pathetic.